Sample report  ·  A real worked example, published with the buyer's permission. Agent and client details removed.
← DeskVal home Negotiation Support — illustrative sample Get one for your property — from $149
DeskVal
The independent second opinion
Negotiation Support · Buyer's Independent Opinion

29 Bowman Drive

Penguin, Tasmania 7316
Reference DeskVal-DAR-2026-0619-v2 · SAMPLE · Prepared 19 June 2026 · Version 2 (independent critique incorporated)
Prepared for
A private purchaser
Prospective purchaser
Confidential — illustrative sample
Verdict — is the $1,100,000 asking price fair?
At fair value — the $1.1M ask sits ~$25,000 below the evidence-led mid of $1,125,000.
Modestly favourable for a buyer if due diligence is clean — but not a bargain. The whole assessment hinges on one unverified number: the floor area. The upper asking guide of $1,295,000 is clearly above the evidence and not supported.
Assessed indicative value range (AUD)
Asking $1.10M
Low
$960,000
Mid · evidence-led
$1,125,000
High
$1,370,000
Property type4-bed established, coastal views
Land area881 m² (advertised)
GFA~327 m² (unverified)
True fair-value band$1,050,000 – $1,150,000
Recommended opening offer$1,040,000
Do not pay above (unverified)$1,150,000
Indicative price opinion — desktop assessment. Not a valuation. Not a registered valuation. This document is not a valuation under the Land Valuers Act 2001 (Tas). No registered valuer has produced or signed this report. It must not be relied upon for financing, taxation, statutory, legal or transactional purposes. Prepared by DeskVal · get@deskval.com.au · for a prospective purchaser only. Published as an illustrative sample with the buyer's permission; agent and client details removed.
DeskVal Desktop Assessment · 29 Bowman Drive, Penguin TAS · Illustrative sample

Section 1Property details

AttributeDetail
Full address29 Bowman Drive, Penguin, Tasmania 7316
Property typeResidential established — two-level contemporary dwelling
Bedrooms / bathrooms4 bed · 2 bath (main + ensuite); 3 toilets (powder room)
Car accommodation2 (double garage, internal access) — estimated
Land area881 m² (advertised; title search recommended to verify)
GFA (gross floor area)~327 m² (from the listing — not independently verified; see GFA sensitivity §5.3 and verification Appendix B)
Year built[TBC] — appears circa 2021–2023 from listing & street context; confirm via Building Permit search with Central Coast Council
Title[TBC] — Standard Freehold assumed; verify on Section 32 equivalent
Zoning[TBC] — General Residential assumed; verify on PlanBuild Tasmania
Orientation / outlookNorth-facing upper level; panoramic Bass Strait ocean views
Key featuresPolished concrete (lower), open-plan upper living, master with WIR + ensuite, office alcove + powder room, second living, split-system A/C, ducted heating, deck & entertaining, fruit trees
ConditionAssumed near-new / good-to-excellent (estimated) — confirm via building & pest
Current listingUpper guide: "Offers Over $1,295,000"; a second agency: $1,100,000 — two competing agency listings, materially different price points (see §5)

1.2  Listing history note

The property appears to have been listed initially at ~$1,350,000 via the upper-guide listing agency (social-media evidence of a "$1.35M" open home on 14 June 2026), with a subsequent "PRICE ADJUSTMENT" post dropping the guide to "Offers Over $1,295,000". A concurrent second-agency listing shows $1,100,000. This dual-agency listing with a $195,000 gap between the two asking prices is a market signal. The buyer has been quoted $1,100,000 as the central question figure; the $1,295,000 upper guide is treated as the vendor's upper price ambition for context only — it is not supported by the evidence in this report.

Why this report exists
Prepared for a prospective purchaser to answer one question: is $1,100,000 fair value, above assessed market value, or below it? It is an independent desktop opinion — no listing to win, no commission, no agenda.

1.3  Location & nearby amenities

Penguin is a coastal town of ~4,100 residents on Tasmania's North-West Coast, between Burnie (~18 km east) and Ulverstone (~13 km west), within the Central Coast Council area — known for its penguin colony, beaches, marine precinct and strong owner-occupier lifestyle appeal. 29 Bowman Drive sits in an elevated coastal subdivision with considerable new development over the past five to ten years; the street's topography gives direct north-facing views over Bass Strait — the primary premium driver in this precinct.

AmenityApprox. distanceAmenityApprox. distance
Penguin town centre & beach1.2 km (est.)Penguin sporting precinct0.5 km (est.)
Penguin Primary School0.9 km (est.)Ulverstone Hospital15 km
Penguin District High School1.1 km (est.)Burnie city centre18 km
Devonport (ferry terminal)45 kmLaunceston Airport~2 hr drive

All distances estimated from mapping tools. Verify if access to a specific amenity is a decision factor.

Section 2Market overview

2.1  Penguin residential market context

Indicator (Penguin 7316)Reading
Median house price$658,000 (PropertyValue) – $681,426 (htag), mid-2026
Subject vs median~62–67% above median at a $1.1M reference price
Annual price growth7.79% (12 mths) vs 4.30% national; 5-yr ~50.89%
Days on market59 days avg · vendor discount −3.91%
Stock / supply39 for sale · 1.4 months of supply (tight)
Rental market$415–$458/wk median · gross yield ~3.17–3.6% · vacancy 0.69%

At a $1.1M reference, the subject sits well above the suburb median. The analysis tests whether the property's attributes — size, views, quality, recent construction — can support that premium. A note of caution on growth: industry guidance warns against applying a single trailing annual rate to a multi-year time adjustment, because regional TAS had a strong 2020–22 cycle followed by a more subdued 2023–24. The §5 methodology reflects this.

2.2  Premium & coastal sub-market

North-West Tasmania recorded 23 sales above $1,000,000 in the June quarter 2025 alone (REIT NW Tas). Premium coastal pockets — Shearwater ($749,500 median), Turners Beach ($747,500), Sisters Beach ($730,000) — show lifestyle-coastal stock commands material premiums over the regional median. Within Penguin the $1M-plus market is thin but active: the strongest recent comparable on the same street — 21 Bowman Drive, sold $1,400,000 (private treaty, 13 May 2025, Domain confirmed) — shows the Bowman Drive precinct has at least one confirmed transaction above $1.1M in the past 14 months.

2.3  Market signal on the unsold listing

76 South Road (listed from $950,000 since December 2025, ~6+ months on market) is an unsold listing and is not treated as comparable evidence. Its failure to transact at $950,000 over six months is itself a signal that demand at the premium end of Penguin is not unlimited. Context only — not relied upon in the methodology.

2.4  Buyer context

No specific state or federal incentive applies to a repeat purchaser. First Home Owner Grant would not apply unless the buyer is a first-home buyer (confirm). Tasmanian stamp duty applies at standard rates. Confirm Home Guarantee Scheme eligibility with a mortgage broker if applicable.

Section 3Comparable market evidence

Data sources. Pricefinder / RP Data not attempted (no paid backend). Free public stack used: REA, Domain (incl. the confirmed C1 settlement), the listing agencies, OldListings, PropertyValue, OnTheHouse, AllHomes, REIT NW Tas Q2 2025, Harrison Agents. The L/M/H range reflects a free-stack evidence base only — access to Pricefinder/CoreLogic would tighten it. Widen-for-uncertainty applied accordingly.

3.1  Comparable sales

#AddressConfigGFA / landPriceDateRelevance
C121 Bowman Drive, Penguin4/2[TBC]$1,400,000
confirmed
May 2025Strongest — same street, same config, likely similar views. GFA unknown. Settlement confirmed via Domain (corrected from v1's "~$1.37M").
C241 Bowman Drive, Penguin3/2240 / 879 m²$900,000Jul 2023Same street, 3-bed, 87 m² smaller, 35 mths old. Sold 16% below list. Floor reference; time adjustment material.
C3109A South Road, Penguin4/2228 m²~$850,0002025 (mth?)Nearby quality 4-bed; 99 m² smaller. Sale month unknown — time-adjustment uncertainty.
C4191 Upper Maud St, W. Ulverstone4/2286 / 1,679 m²$1,145,0002025Adjacent municipality, ocean views, MBA Award finalist 2024. Quality benchmark; location premium applied for Bowman Dr.

C5 (76 South Road, listed $950,000, Dec 2025) removed from the table — an unsold listing for 6+ months is not comparable evidence (see §2.3).

3.2  Market depth commentary

Evidence at and above $1,100,000 in Penguin is thin. The only confirmed above-$1M sale on the same street is C1 at $1,400,000, but its GFA is unconfirmed. The next strongest (C2 at $900,000, Jul 2023) is 35 months old with a different configuration. The subject's estimated ~327 m² is large for Penguin; at C1's $1.4M the implied rate on the subject's GFA would be ~$4,281/m², but that can't be stress-tested without C1's actual GFA. A wider-than-usual spread (±15%) is warranted given the thin high-end base and the unverified GFA.

3.3  Rental evidence

Market rent for a quality 4-bed in Penguin is estimated at $600–$700/wk (suburb median $415–$458 plus a premium-build, coastal-view uplift). Estimate only — no specific 4-bed coastal rental comparable found on the free stack. Cross-check purposes only.

Section 4Desktop assessment

Valuation uncertainty — desktop basis only. The range below is derived entirely from publicly available listing and market data. No physical inspection. No confirmed settlement data from paid sources beyond what is publicly visible on Domain. Findings carry significant inherent uncertainty and must not be relied upon as a registered property assessment.

Approach 1 — Direct comparable sales

The primary method compares the subject to sold properties, adjusting for time, size and configuration. The subject is treated as a 4-bed, 2-bath, 2-car, ~327 m² GFA (unverified), 881 m² land, near-new, north-facing coastal-view dwelling on Bowman Drive.

Time-adjustment methodology (revised from v1)

v1 applied a single 8.5% p.a. rate from the trailing 12-month figure. The critique correctly flagged that as methodologically fragile across a multi-year window. This report now applies 7.79% p.a. for short sub-periods (0–14 mths, 2025–26) and 5.5–6.5% p.a. (6.0% central) for longer sub-periods (14–36 mths, 2023–25), reflecting subdued 2023–24 growth.

Adjusted comparables

CompBasisAdjusted value
C1 — 21 Bowman Dr$1,400,000 confirmed × 1.0844 (13 mths) × 0.90 (GFA-uncertainty discount)~$1,370,000 (ceiling)
C2 — 41 Bowman Dr$900,000 × 1.175 (6.0% p.a., 35 mths) × 1.08 (config/size)~$1,142,000
C3 — 109A South Rd$850,000 × 1.078 (mid-2025) × 1.18 (size) × 1.05 (view premium)~$1,135,000
C4 — 191 Upper Maud St$1,145,000 × 1.0779 (12 mths) × 1.03 (location premium)~$1,271,000

Approach 1 reconciliation

ParameterLowMidHigh
C2 / C3 conservative average$1,111,000
C2 + C3 + C4 mid average$1,182,667
C1 confirmed ceiling$1,370,000
Evidence-quality discount−5%−5%0%
Approach 1 indicated$1,050,000$1,125,000$1,370,000
Material change from v1 — confirmation bias removed
v1 set the Mid at $1,100,000 by rounding down to match the asking price. The critique identified this as confirmation bias — anchoring the buyer's assessment to the vendor's price rather than the evidence. The evidence-led Mid is $1,125,000. The $1.1M ask therefore sits ~$25,000 below the Mid — modestly favourable for the buyer if due diligence is clean, but not the "at fair value snap" v1 implied.

Approach 2 — Rental yield cross-check

ParameterConservativeBaseOptimistic
Market rent / week$580$640$700
Annual gross rent$30,160$33,280$36,400
Applied gross yield4.2%3.8%3.4%
Indicated value$718,000$876,000$1,071,000

The yield cross-check produces a materially lower range — expected for premium coastal lifestyle property. Yield-driven investors (3.5–4.5% gross) are not the primary buyer at $1M-plus in Penguin; the buyer universe is owner-occupier dominated (families, sea-changers, retirees with capital), who routinely pay a premium for lifestyle, views and amenity. Approach 1 is treated as primary; Approach 2 (~$718k–$1,071k) is the investor-value floor.

4.3  GFA sensitivity

The subject's ~327 m² GFA is unverified, and listings routinely overstate floor area by including the garage (~40–50 m²) and alfresco. The likely conditioned area may be 275–310 m². Implied rate per square metre at various GFA assumptions:

Assumed GFA@ $1.0M@ $1.1M ask@ $1.125M mid@ $1.3MC2 benchmark
275 m²$3,636$4,000$4,091$4,727$3,750
290 m²$3,448$3,793$3,879$4,483$3,750
310 m²$3,226$3,548$3,629$4,194$3,750
327 m² (listing)$3,058$3,364$3,440$3,977$3,750
The single most important pre-offer check
If the true conditioned GFA is 275–290 m² (realistic if the garage is excluded), the buyer at $1.1M is paying at or above the C2 rate per m², and the evidence-led Mid moves down toward $1,050,000–$1,080,000. If GFA is 310 m² or more, $1.1M is comfortably supportable. Confirming GFA from the building permit before offering is the one step that most tightens this assessment.

4.4  Reconciled value range

LowMidHigh
Indicative range (AUD)$960,000$1,125,000$1,370,000
ScenarioConservative C2/C3; GFA below 327 m²; thin evidenceEvidence-led avg of C2+C3+C4, corrected rates, −5%C1 confirmed $1.4M time-adjusted, −10% GFA

True fair-value band: applying GFA uncertainty to the Mid, the most likely fair-value band — if GFA verifies at 310 m² or above — is $1,050,000 – $1,150,000. If GFA verifies at or near 327 m², the top extends toward $1,125,000–$1,175,000.

On the $1,295,000 upper guide
Clearly above the evidence-based Mid and not independently supported. No single reasonable correction lifts the Mid to $1,295,000. The only ceiling reference is C1 at $1,400,000 time-adjusted — and a 10% GFA-uncertainty discount already brings that to $1,370,000, still below the upper guide. Paying $1,295,000 is imprudent without independent GFA verification and a confirmed C1 GFA comparison.

Section 5Buyer verdict & offer strategy

Summary verdict
$1,100,000 sits ~$25,000 below the evidence-led Mid of $1,125,000.
A ~2.3% gap — well within normal negotiating tolerance. Modestly favourable for the buyer if due diligence is clean, but not so wide that the purchaser can expect to acquire materially below fair value. The $1,295,000 upper guide remains clearly unsupported (~$170,000 above the evidence Mid).

Corrected offer strategy

Offer levelAmountBasis
Opening position$1,020,000 – $1,040,000Below evidence Low; tests vendor motivation while GFA & C1 GFA unverified
Acceptable range$1,040,000 – $1,080,000Low to mid of the corrected range; reasonable value with DD conditions
Strong competitive offer$1,100,000Slightly below the evidence Mid; fair if GFA verifies ≥310 m² and B&P is clean
Post-verification walk-away$1,130,000 – $1,150,000Stretch only if GFA ≥310 m² confirmed, C1 GFA confirmed larger, and B&P clear. Replaces v1's unsupported $1,175,000.
Do NOT pay (unverified)Above $1,150,000Not supported by current evidence

Recommended opening offer: $1,040,000 subject to finance and building/pest inspection. Do not pay $1,295,000.

Five-year hold context

General information only — not a forecast, not investment advice.

Entry price5% p.a. (5 yr)6% p.a. (5 yr)7% p.a. (5 yr)
$1,050,000$1,340,000$1,405,000$1,473,000
$1,100,000$1,404,000$1,472,000$1,543,000
$1,125,000$1,436,000$1,506,000$1,578,000

At ~6% p.a. (the implied 5-year compounded rate), the $1,295,000 upper guide becomes consistent with the forward value from a $1.05–1.1M entry in roughly 3–4 years (~2029–2030). That assumption is not guaranteed.

Section 6Value drivers & risk register

6.1  Positive value drivers

FactorImpactCommentary
North-facing ocean viewsHighThe single most significant premium driver here; confirmed C1 sale demonstrates the market recognises it.
Contemporary build qualityHigh"Highly respected local builder"; near-new stock commands a premium over Penguin's median housing.
Floor area (~327 m²)Mod (contingent)If confirmed, generously large for Penguin. Materially reduced if conditioned area is 275–290 m².
Dual living / flexibilityModerateLower level functions as a semi-independent zone — families, multigen, guest suite.
Motivated-seller signalsModerateTwo price reductions ($1.35M → $1.295M → a second agency at $1.1M) suggest adjusted expectations; buyer leverage.
Tight supply (1.4 mths)ModerateLow stock relative to demand supports current price levels.
Ask below evidence MidLow–Mod$1.1M is ~$25k below the evidence-led Mid — a marginal buyer-side advantage if DD is clean.

6.2  Risk factors

FactorImpactCommentary
GFA not verifiedHigh327 m² is off the listing and includes the garage. If conditioned area is 275–290 m², size-adjusted Mid falls to $1,050k–$1,080k. Confirm via building permit before committing.
Year built unknownHighNo confirmed construction year. Building & pest mandatory; request builder warranty docs.
Dual-agency $195k gapHigh$1.1M vs $1.295M on the same house. Clarify the sale mechanism with both agencies before any offer (Appendix B-E).
C1 GFA unknownHighThe only confirmed $1M+ street sale has unknown GFA. If C1 is larger, the subject's implied rate at $1.1M may exceed C1's.
Thin high-end compsModerateFewer than 3 confirmed $1M+ closed sales in 24 months on the free stack; High end rests on one data point.
Coastal hazard overlayModerateElevated position likely protects against inundation; erosion band may differ. LISTmap check required (Appendix B-C, free). An overlay could cut value $30k–$60k.
C3 sale month unknownModerate~$75k uncertainty on C3 from the unknown month alone.
Zoning / overlays (TBC)ModerateAny overlay beyond General Residential may restrict alterations/development.
Rental-yield compressionLow–ModGross yield 2.7–3.2% at the Mid — below suburb average; relevant if ever rented.
Thin premium liquidityLow–ModResale at this point may take materially longer than the 59-day suburb average.
Title / encumbrances (TBC)LowNo title search conducted; confirm easements/caveats with a conveyancer.

Section 7Buyer verification checklist

For the purchaser to hand to their conveyancer, buyers agent or solicitor. Complete items A, B and C before making any offer. D, E and F can proceed in parallel.

A
Building permit search — subject GFA  Priority

Confirm 29 Bowman Drive's actual approved floor area — specifically conditioned living area, separate from garage/alfresco — via Central Coast Council (or PlanBuild Tasmania).

Cost/time: free or nominal · 2–5 business days  ·  Impact: if ≥310 m², $1.1M supportable & walk-away may extend to $1,130k–$1,150k; if ≤275 m², Mid falls to $1,050k–$1,080k.
B
Permit / brochure for 21 Bowman Drive — C1 GFA  Priority

Confirm the GFA of the $1.4M C1 comparable via OldListings, Domain sold history, or the Council DA register. If C1 is larger than the subject, $1.1M is below C1 on a $/m² basis (positive).

Cost/time: free · 1–2 days  ·  Impact: resolves the single biggest uncertainty in the High case.
C
LISTmap coastal-hazard overlay check  Priority

At maps.thelist.tas.gov.au, enable "Coastal Erosion Hazard" and "Coastal Inundation Hazard" layers on the lot. "No overlay" is the best outcome.

Cost/time: free · under 5 minutes  ·  Impact: an overlay could reduce lender appetite and resale value; revise walk-away down $30k–$60k.
D
Building & pest inspection + builder warranty

Engage a QBIS-accredited inspector; request all builder-warranty documentation; confirm the builder and statutory defects-liability period.

Cost/time: ~$500–$800 · 3–5 days  ·  Impact: any defect is leverage to renegotiate.
E
Clarify the dual-agency arrangement

Ask each agency separately: exclusive or conjunctional? Can the vendor accept independently of the other agency? Is the $1.1M lower guide fixed or negotiable? How long marketed, any prior offers? Do not disclose your maximum.

Cost/time: free · 30–60 min  ·  Impact: defines whether you have leverage or a competitive situation.
F
Title, zoning & planning search

Title search via the Tasmanian Land Titles Office (through your conveyancer); zoning, overlays and open DAs via PlanBuild Tasmania.

Cost/time: ~$30–$50 title · PlanBuild free  ·  Impact: confirms no planning encumbrances.

Section 8Assumptions, limiting conditions & sources

8.1  Key assumptions

8.2  Limiting conditions

This document is an indicative price opinion produced by an automated desktop process. It is not a valuation under the Land Valuers Act 2001 (Tas); no registered valuer has produced or signed it. It relies exclusively on publicly available information as at 19 June 2026. No physical inspection has been conducted. No investigation has been made into structural soundness, asbestos, contamination, or building-code compliance. Comparable evidence is from free public sources only. This assessment does not constitute financial product advice; it must not be relied upon for financing, statutory, legal or transactional purposes without further verification by qualified professionals.

Final disclaimer — indicative price opinion. Not a valuation. Not a registered valuation.
Before any acquisition, financing, disposal or investment decision, obtain a formal registered valuation from a qualified, independent property valuer experienced in the North-West Tasmania market. Prepared as a prospective purchaser's desktop analysis and for no other purpose; it must not be distributed to or relied upon by any third party, lender or financier. General information only — not personal financial product advice.

8.3  Selected sources

  1. Listing agency A — 29 Bowman Drive listing (incl. price-adjustment history).
  2. Listing agency B — 29 Bowman Drive listing ($1,100,000).
  3. Domain — 21 Bowman Drive sold $1,400,000 (private treaty, 13 May 2025) — C1 confirmed settlement.
  4. PropertyValue.com.au & htag.com.au — Penguin 7316 suburb statistics.
  5. OnTheHouse / Domain — 41 Bowman Drive ($900,000, 18 Jul 2023, 240 m²).
  6. Ulverstone Real Estate — 191 Upper Maud St ($1,145,000, 286 m², ocean views).
  7. REIT North West Tasmania — June Quarter 2025 Media Release (23 sales $1M+).
  8. CBOS Tasmania — coastal inundation hazard areas; Central Coast Council Planning Scheme.
Prepared by DeskVal
get@deskval.com.au · 19 June 2026 · Illustrative sample · Reference DeskVal-DAR-2026-0619-v2
DeskVal

Want this on your property?

This is the Negotiation Support tier ($349) — the full report plus a buyer offer strategy and a counter-position to the agent's price. Independent, no listing to win, no commission.

← Back to DeskVal home
Get one for your property — from $149